Bone Mineral Density and its Relation to Cruciate Ligament
Strength in the Tibiofemoral Joint. Travis Jones, David J.
Porta, Ph.D, Bellarmine University, Louisville, KY 40205.
Sponsor: David Porta, Ph.D
This study was conducted so as to compare the bone mineral
density with cruciate ligament strength within the knee joint.
Four male and four female embalmed cadavers, ages 62 to 93,
were studied. Forearm bone mineral density (BMD) was
measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) using a
DTX-200 Osteometer. BMD scans showed significant
differences between males and females (P<0.0001), but no
significant differences between dominant and non-dominant
arms (P=0.9676). Further analysis of the density scans showed
expected results with the lowest BMD correlating with the
lowest bone mineral content (BMC). Data also showed an
expected higher BMD mean for males (0.427+/-0.055 g/cm2)
versus females (0.335 +/-0.155 g/cm2 ). Both knee joints were
then dissected out of each cadaver and manually torqued
laterally. Force values were compared with BMD. Upon
examination of the knee ligaments, we were able to predict
anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) failure would occur first.
Three failure modes were observed including an ACL tear
with minimal PCL damage (69%), tibial avulsion fracture
(25%), and failure of the test set-up (6%). Our data indicates
ligament strength does not correlate with BMD (r=-0.442963)
or BMC (r=-0.32055). However, it appears that specimens
with low BMD and BMC levels may be more prone to tibial
avulsion fractures during knee torsion.