Thinking about a Ph.D.?  Here’s how to choose the right one 

You have worked long enough to recognize the questions that keep coming back. Why does a strategy or initiative help some students but miss others? What makes organizational change last? How can a school, university, or community organization make better decisions about the people it serves? 

Those questions can be the beginning of a doctoral journey. Choosing a Ph.D. starts with understanding what you want to investigate, where you want to make a difference, and how you want to grow as a leader. The right program should connect those ambitions to the research preparation and learning environment you need. 

For professionals considering education-related doctoral study, Bellarmine University offers two paths worth exploring: the Ph.D. in Education and Social Change and the Ph.D. in Higher Education Leadership. They share an interest in leadership and educational opportunity but bring different settings and questions into focus.  

This blog post is designed to share a bit more information about our programs and to give you a few questions to consider as you consider which PhD program might be the right choice for your future.  

Start with a question you want to understand 

Before comparing course schedules, write down a challenge you would like to understand more deeply. Be specific enough to move beyond a broad interest such as “helping students” or “becoming a better leader.”  

Perhaps you want to understand how families experience a community learning program. Perhaps you are interested in the decisions that influence whether adult students return to college. You might want to examine how educators adopt a new approach or how university policies affect students with different responsibilities outside the classroom. For instance, students have examined the influence of family literacy playgroups on second language learners, the lived experiences of refugees resettling in Kentucky, and the role of teacher bias in student discipline. 

You do not need a finished dissertation proposal before you begin exploring programs. In fact, it is likely that this initial wondering will not end up being your dissertation study, although we almost never say never. An initial question gives you something useful to discuss with faculty and can help you frame your assignments in the first several courses as you build research skills and get more comfortable with statistical analysis and qualitative rigor. It also helps you distinguish a program that simply sounds appealing from one that can substantively support the work you hope to do. 

Consider where you want your work to matter 

Think about the setting in which you want to contribute. Is your interest centered on schools, community organizations, advocacy, or the relationships among them? The PhD in Education and Social Change might be right for you. Are you most interested in the policies and decisions that shape colleges and universities? The PhD in Higher Education Leadership might be the best fit for your interests and career goals. 

Bellarmine’s Education and Social Change program addresses learning, access, and outcomes across education-related settings, like schools, nonprofits, and community organizations. Higher Education Leadership focuses more specifically on postsecondary institutions and the work of leading within them. These interests can overlap. A college employee might want to investigate a community issue that extends beyond a campus. A nonprofit professional might want to study a partnership with a university. Treat the distinction as a starting point for a conversation about your research interests, rather than a rule based on your current job title. Also consider what you might want to do next—looking at the CVs or resumes of the people who currently have the role you aspire to get can give you crucial information about the kind of degree that may help open the door to your next step.  

Read the curriculum with your goals beside you 

Our catalog is public and can help you learn more about what it would actually look like to be a Bellarmine PhD student. The program names and broad descriptions can tell you the general focus, but reading the course descriptions can help you to understand what you will study once you’re enrolled. As you read through them, consider how you’d like to grow as a learner, a thinker, and a researcher. 

As you determine which program may be a better fit, notice the shared curriculum—both the Education and Social Change and the Higher Education Leadership PhD programs equip students to evaluate research and design and implement studies—and the differences between the programs.  Look for a sequence of learning that connects your goals to increasingly independent work. 

Notice how students move from learning research methods in beginning courses like EDUG 859 and EDRE 800 to using them in EDRE 802, EDRE 804, and EDUG 900. Feel free to browse completed dissertations here. A description of a research course becomes much more meaningful when you can see the questions students have investigated and the work they produced. 

Look for faculty who can help you develop your thinking 

Faculty fit deserves attention early in your search. For any program you are considering, read faculty biographies and recent scholarship, then ask who might be able to support your interests. You are looking for relevant expertise and a productive working relationship. 

A useful conversation should help you sharpen your question. A faculty member might suggest a different way to define the problem, point you toward existing research, or explain why a proposed study would be difficult to conduct. That feedback can reveal more about the learning experience than a general program overview. 

Schedule a time to chat with the chair of the program. At Bellarmine, that’s either Dr. Archibald (jarchibald@bellarmine.edu) for Higher Education Leadership or Dr. Smith (jsmith89@bellarmine.edu) for Education and Social Change to ask your questions. Students commonly want to know more about how advising works (you meet with a faculty member each semester to select courses and touch base on evolving goals), how dissertation committees are formed (you select your team based on methodological and content expertise), and what happens if your interests evolve (we pivot [like a couch on an apartment stairwell]). These questions vary from school to school but make a big difference in your experience of a program. 

Picture the program inside an ordinary week 

Imagine a week with work deadlines, family commitments, and an unexpected interruption. Where would reading, writing and research fit? What would need to change for you to protect that time consistently? How does that vary based on the format or modality of the program you select? 

An online format can make participation more accessible, but you still need a realistic plan for the work. Ask about scheduled meetings (synchronous Teams meetings once per month), assignment deadlines (which vary by course), group projects (which are flexible but help with learning and connecting across the cohort), and campus attendance (you’re welcome any time but only expected on campus during our summer intensive in early July each year). Clarify which commitments are predictable and which may change during the dissertation stage. 

Both Bellarmine programs are designed for working professionals with full lives. Our students have jobs, families, and responsibilities that would make a traditional residential PhD less appropriate for their current circumstances. Our PhD programs are primarily online with on-campus intensive experiences, and the connection with faculty and classmates remains a significant priority. As cheesy as it may sound, we often talk about the program as being “online, but not alone.”  

Think about the people you will learn alongside 

A doctoral cohort can bring different professional experiences into the same conversation. Consider what you hope to learn from peers and what perspective you would contribute. 

Ask how students collaborate, how discussions connect to their professional settings, and whether you can speak with a current student. You might ask what surprised them about the workload, how they organize their writing time, and what they wish they had understood before enrolling. 

Listen for specific examples. You want a clear picture of the learning community, including how students challenge ideas respectfully and support one another through demanding work. 

Define what a worthwhile outcome looks like 

Career advancement may be part of your motivation, and we do not mean to diminish that goal—it’s what drove many of Bellarmine’s faculty to PhD study. We do want to encourage you to give equal attention to the work you want to become capable of doing: evaluating an initiative, conducting original research, informing policy or helping an organization make a better decision. 

Grab a pen and write a short statement beginning, “I want doctoral study to help me…” Then test each program you look at against it. Discuss total costs, time commitments, and dissertation expectations alongside your academic interests. Consider how relationships with faculty may shape the experience. A thoughtful choice should hold up both intellectually and practically. 

You do not have to resolve every question before contacting a program! We are happy to help answer your questions and clarify your thinking. Bring your experience, your curiosity and a problem you care about. Explore Bellarmine’s Education and Social Change and Higher Education Leadership programs, then talk with Dr. Smith (jsmith89@bellarmine.edu) or Dr. Archibald (jarchibald@bellarmine.edu) about where your interests could lead.