Before you choose a Ph.D., read this:
Six questions to ask
For many professionals, the idea of pursuing a Ph.D. begins with a question they can't quite let go of. You want to investigate a persistent problem, contribute to a larger conversation or prepare for responsibilities that require a deeper understanding of education and leadership.
That motivation matters, and so does understanding what you are committing to. A doctoral program will become part of your working life, your household schedule, and your long-term plans. As you explore your options, it's worth considering what you need from a program and how different programs might fit into your life.
Whether Bellarmine University is one of several schools on your list or you're just beginning to explore doctoral programs, these six questions can help you think about what matters most to you. Every doctoral program has its own strengths, and the best choice depends on the questions you want to explore, the experiences you bring, and the kind of scholar you hope to become.
1. What do I want to be able to do differently?
It can be helpful to think about what you'd like to do with your doctorate, beyond earning the credential itself. What would you like to understand, investigate, or lead more effectively?
A school or nonprofit professional might want to evaluate whether an educational initiative is reaching the people it was intended to serve. A college administrator might want to understand how institutional decisions shape student experiences. Someone working across organizations might want to investigate why a promising partnership succeeds in one setting and struggles in another.
These are illustrative starting points, not prescribed dissertation topics. Use your own experience to identify a question worth exploring. Then ask faculty how the curriculum could help you develop the skills to study it responsibly and communicate what you learn.
2. Am I interested in the research process?
Think about how you respond when evidence complicates your expectations. How might your professional experiences and interests shape the research you want to pursue? Are you willing to revisit a strongly held view? Can you stay with a question when the answer is uncertain?
Research requires more than gathering information that supports an idea. You will need to consider alternative explanations, examine the quality of evidence and make careful decisions about what your findings can support. Your professional experience can help you notice important questions, but those questions still need systematic investigation.
Before applying, read a completed dissertation in an area that interests you. You do not need to understand every method immediately. Notice how the author defines the problem, connects it to prior work and explains the limits of the study. Ask whether that kind of sustained inquiry appeals to you. You might also ask how different programs approach research preparation, since the opportunities to develop your interests as a researcher can vary considerably.
3. How will the program fit my actual schedule?
As you compare programs, consider how their different schedules might fit into the life you already have. Think about your responsibilities, including work hours, commuting, caregiving, rest, and the other things you cannot easily move. Then identify where focused study could realistically happen.
While exploring a program, ask about the time students typically spend on reading, writing, and assignments. At Bellarmine, our students typically spend about 15–20 hours each week reading, writing, meeting with faculty or one another, and engaging with course content.
It's also worth asking about attendance requirements, live online meetings, and any travel to campus. In Bellarmine's Ph.D. in Education and Social Change, classes meet synchronously on Teams once per month for two hours, with the remaining coursework completed around students' schedules. We also come together for one long weekend each July to connect across cohorts, meet with faculty, and participate in workshops and conversations with guest speakers. As you explore your options, consider whether program schedules change during the summer or dissertation phase.
4. What does dissertation support look like?
Ask about the dissertation while you are still comparing programs. Find out when students begin developing a topic, how they identify an advisor, and what milestones guide their progress. At Bellarmine, students work closely with faculty to review existing research, develop an original research question, and select an appropriate methodology. They then assemble a dissertation committee that includes experts from within and outside the university, who help guide their work as they develop and defend a research proposal. Following Institutional Review Board approval, students collect and analyze their data, interpret their findings, and ultimately share their contributions to the field through a written dissertation and public defense. Throughout this process, students meet regularly with their faculty advisors, typically for 30 minutes every other week, although the frequency and format of meetings can be adjusted to meet individual needs.
It can be helpful to understand the steps between a promising idea and an approved study. Who helps students assess whether a question is manageable? How do they prepare for research involving people? What happens if access to participants or data changes?
The nature of the feedback students receive is another important consideration. As you explore programs, discuss meeting frequency, expectations for drafts and the support available when a student encounters a methodological challenge. Understanding the process helps you plan for a stage of study that may feel quite different from completing scheduled courses.
5. What is the full financial commitment?
Review the preparation expected for positions or responsibilities that interest you. Look at actual job descriptions and talk with people familiar with that work. Consider experience, research skills, and other requirements alongside the degree. Even within the same university, two doctoral programs can offer very different experiences and prepare students to investigate different kinds of questions.
Bellarmine offers two distinct Ph.D. programs that reflect different scholarly interests and professional goals. The Ph.D. in Higher Education Leadership focuses specifically on leadership within colleges and universities, while the Ph.D. in Education and Social Change takes a broader, interdisciplinary approach to studying education and its relationship to social change. If a particular credential, certification, or endorsement is essential to your plans, confirm that separately. A candid conversation about fit can help you avoid choosing a program simply because its title sounds close to your goal.
6. What evidence would help me feel ready to decide?
By this point, you may have several brochures and a growing list of questions. Identify what is still missing. Perhaps you need to speak with a faculty member, review a dissertation, look at the required courses, or understand the total cost more clearly. It may be helpful to consider how the programs you're exploring compare on the questions that matter most to you.
You may not have every detail of the next several years figured out, and that's okay. Whether your search ultimately leads you to Bellarmine or another institution, we hope these questions help you find a program that fits your interests, ambitions, and life. If Bellarmine is part of that search, we'd welcome the opportunity to talk with you about your goals and answer your questions. You can reach out to Dr. Archibald (jarchibald@bellarmine.edu) for Higher Education Leadership or Dr. Smith (jsmith89@bellarmine.edu) for Education and Social Change.